The apparent move away from the instructional approach is flagged in a new discussion paper released as part of AITSL’s current review of the Standards.

Input from stakeholders and research efforts so far suggests that inclusive whole-class instruction, ongoing assessment to inform teaching, and increasingly targeted and intensive supports – such as those within an MTSS model – ought to replace the longstanding focus on differentiation. 

Educators and experts have previously warned that the term ‘differentiation’ is an inherently murky one within the teaching profession, with varying understandings and practical applications attached to it. 

“A range of alternative terms, such as ‘inclusive teaching’ and ‘responsive teaching’, may be considered as more reflective of the broader knowledge teachers require, and more inclusive than the narrower and more practice-oriented term ‘differentiation’,” AITSL’s paper proposes. 

One secondary teacher from Melbourne told EducationHQ that differentiation had been a definite buzzword at her school, with leadership instructing teachers to deliver their lessons in multiple ways in order to cater to students’ diverse learning needs and preferences. 

But the term hasn’t really been uttered at all this year, the teacher reported. 

“I do feel like it’s dropped off – but no one’s really addressed why.

“Differentiation is certainly used with children who have mandated support in the classroom. We talk about how we might differentiate for them, but not in terms of just an average classroom.”

Having taught in the public school system for over 40 years, the teacher said in her experience it was a real challenge to try and do differentiation well for 20-plus students at the same time. 

“I think teachers are probably skilled in naturally differentiating in some ways. If something doesn’t work with some students, then you try and find another way around it – but you do that in the moment.”

Differentiating for the whole class tended to mean that smaller group work would simply replace whole-class instruction a lot of the time, the teacher noted. 

“I think it’s exceedingly difficult to manage and differentiate for a whole classroom, using all these different techniques. What would mostly happen is, we would set the task and the students would work at their own pace – so we were more of a facilitator, an assister on the side. 

“It killed a lot of explicit instruction for a while. But now we’ve moved back to explicit instruction a lot more as a component of lessons,” the teacher reported. 

The practice was also tied up in disability funding, they noted. 

“I had a student who was receiving mandated support and, in order to get their funding, for 13 weeks each one of her teachers had to write-up how we were differentiating each lesson to cater to that student.

“So, the workload was significant.” 

“Gone are the days of teachers being told to plan 20 different lessons for one single class! Well, hopefully,” one school leader has said in response to the discussion paper.

According to former primary teacher Dr Nathaniel Swain, now a senior lecturer in learning sciences at La Trobe University, it’s entirely possible to be a responsive, adaptive and differentiated teacher without having to split your instruction into many different parts.

Swain has said previously that whole class explicit teaching is the ‘sweet spot’ of differentiation, because it targets a single learning objective with rigorous modelling, practice and feedback. 

He warned that both streaming various tasks and splitting students into ability groups can cause a range of problems, such as potentially locking students into certain levels of achievement. 

This kind of ‘small-scale streaming’ also inevitably widens the learning gap, he added. 

“You’re going to actually push each of those groups further apart, rather than bringing them back together.” 

AITSL have now concluded that focus area 1.5 in the Standards – ‘Differentiate teaching to meet the specific learning needs of students across the full range of abilities’ – demonstrates a ‘misalignment with the evidence’. 

Caiti Wade, Head of Professional Practice & Pedagogy at a Brisbane secondary school and co-host of the When Will They Learn? podcast, shared her surprise over this assessment in a Substack post. 

“My jaw nearly hit the floor when I read this,” she wrote.

“Long has this been the focus area that I would describe as the bane of my teaching standard existence when it comes with working with teachers across schools, but there’s now acknowledgment that it doesn’t align with the evidence?! 

“To make matters even better, the evidence referenced also included a note about multi-tiered systems of support (MTSS) – now that is some inclusion gold!” 

Wade also praises the discussion paper’s assertion that effective inclusive education is a shared responsibility, and that “expectations must remain reasonable and achievable for individual teachers”. 

“While teachers play a critical role in identifying and responding to learners’ needs, effective implementation relies on supportive school and system leadership, appropriate resourcing and collaboration with other professionals,” the paper states. 

“Gone are the days of teachers being told to plan 20 different lessons for one single class! Well, hopefully,” Wade concludes.

“This is a very clear and explicit acknowledgment that inclusive education cannot rest solely on the shoulders of individual teachers – and I’m pretty impressed it’s been included in a review of the standards against which individual teachers are ‘assessed’ (for want of a better word).” 

All members of the education and broader community are invited to respond to the discussion paper via written submission or an online survey. More details can be found here.

A final report is due to be submitted to education ministers in March 2027. It will outline options and AITSL’s recommendations for improving the Teacher Standards.